February 26, 2004

So, What Should the Amendment Be?

Daniel Drezner has an amusing challenge about the same sex marriage debate. From the 203 comments (and counting) it would appear that the majority of people oppose gay marriage but support civil unions. According to Andrew and a number of others, the proposed amendment would also ban civil unions, so it's unlikely to even get out of the gate as is. Question:

What would an amendment banning same sex marriage, but allowing civil unions, look like? What are those unique aspects of marriage that would be excluded from civil unions? Divorce requirements? Child support obligations? Property claims. Standing in contests over custody? I just can't fathom it, and need help. What are the dimensions of this controversy, really?

Posted by Demosophist at February 26, 2004 10:14 PM | TrackBack
Comments